Up: Martin Poulter > Scientology Criticism > UK Media Archive

Scientology "Dangerous and Corrupt"

East Grinstead Courier, Thursday 26 July 1984

A HIGH COURT Judge has made the most outspoken condemnation yet of the Church of Scientology, which has its British headquarters it Saint Hill Manor, East Grinstead. He condemned it as "corrupt, sinister and dangerous".

Its founder, former, American science fiction writer L. Ron Hubbard and his Wife Mary Sue were condemned by Mr Justice Latey as "charlatan and worse."

And the sect, said the judge was "both immoral and socially obnoxious."

Hubbard and his helpers were said to be "grimly reminiscent of the ranting and bullying of Hitler and his henchmen".

Sir Geoffrey Johnston Smith, former East Grinstead MP and now representing [illegible] is to ask the Home Secretary if, in view of the judge comments, he will order a departmental inquiry into the activities of Scientology.

"I have had people quite recently come to see me concerned about the effects this organization is having on their family relationships," said Sir Geoffrey.

Scientology, which has been struggling to improve its image with a series of widely publicised reforms, found itself in the na tional newspaper headlines on Tuesday, after considerable exposure on radio and television the night before.

The judgment by Mr Justice Latey in the High Court came unheralded. He had been hearing in private a dispute about the custody of two children. Then he went into open court to order a father, aged 32, who is a Scientologist seven-year-old son and eight-year-old daughter to their mother. She is 28 and had fought for almost six years to be reunited with them after she broke away from the Scientology.

The judge ordered the Church of Scientology to stop intimidating and harassing the mother, warning that failure to do so would be dealt with, with the "utmost severity."

The father has since remarried.


Mr Justice Latey said Scientology was corrupt "because it is based on ties and deceit, and has as its real objective, money and power for its founder, his wife and those close to him at the top.

"It is sinister because it indulges in infamous practices, both to its adherents who do not toe. the line unquestioningly, and to those outside who criticise or oppose it.

"It is dangerous because it is out to capture young people, especially children and impressionable young people and indoctrinate and brainwash them so that they become the unquestioning captives and tools of the cult, withdrawn from ordinary thought, living and relationships with others."

The judge praised the mother's courage in escaping from the "tight and unrelenting" hold of Scientology and its ruthless discipline.

He said the children were at a school controlled by Scientologists where the "baleful influence" was ever present and the objectives were tb capture the child's mind. It would be a grave risk to leave them with the father, but they still loved him and he loved them regular visits should be arranged.

Mr Justice Latey's reason for giving judgment in open court he described as "a warning to others."

The judge made a detailed attack on the character of Hubbard. He was not, as claimed wounded in the war and decorated. It was false to claim that he had been crippled and blinded, then cured by Scientology techniques.

Hubbard, said the judge, had disappeared and was being sought by US police.

L. Ron Hubbard was a wel lknown figure in East Grinstead where he established Saint Hill as the world headquarters of his movement. In August 1983 the Scientologists announced that they had "kicked out" 12 key members of their UK headquarters staff at Saint Hill as part of a policy change.

Subsequently splinter groups have emerged and challenge the Church of Scientology's monopoly on Hubbard's teachings.

[picture of Hubbard]

L RON HUBBARD as he was In his East grinstead days. He is now 72

Up: Martin Poulter > Scientology Criticism > UK Media Archive